READING LAGS BEHIND: SKILL-SPECIFIC ENGLISH PROFICIENCY GAPS AMONG MANAGEMENT STUDENTS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR ESP CURRICULUM

Authors

  • Diah Kurniati Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author
  • Atik Rokhayani Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author
  • Yuanita Damayanti Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author
  • Pipit Ambarsari Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author
  • Dina Novita Wijayanti Universitas Muria Kudus, Kudus, Indonesia Author

Keywords:

reading proficiency; skill gaps; English for specific purposes; CEFR; management students; Indonesian higher education

Abstract

Reading is the skill through which business students meet their discipline, yet little is known about how reading develops relative to other English skills among Indonesian management students. This study examines skill-specific proficiency gaps, with a focus on reading, among management students in an Indonesian business faculty and draws implications for the English for specific purposes (ESP) curriculum. EnglishScore results for grammar, vocabulary, listening and reading were analysed for 235 students tested in the even semester of the 2025/2026 academic year. A reading gap index, the difference between each student's reading score and the mean of their other three skills, was calculated alongside CEFR band comparisons and regression analysis. Reading was the weakest skill (M = 175.6) and trailed vocabulary by 18.9 points on average. Two-thirds of students (155; 66.0%) read below the level of their other skills, 67 (28.5%) by 25 points or more, and 74.0% scored below the A2 threshold in reading. Crucially, the reading gap widened with proficiency (Spearman ρ = −.37, p < .001): it was negligible among the lowest-scoring quarter of students, reached −23.3 points in the highest quarter, and was largest at A2, where reading trailed vocabulary by 55 points. Vocabulary and grammar together predicted 87% of the variance in reading, while listening contributed little. These findings suggest that as students gain words and structures, their ability to process connected text does not keep pace. The study proposes a reading-led ESP curriculum that bridges words to texts at A1, builds guided business reading at A2 and develops genre-based business literacy from B1, supported by carefully levelled materials and regular assessment.

Downloads

Published

2026-10-14

Issue

Section

Articles